06Jan03 Added JM's stone-test-2 from newsgroup posting Stat Newt Candy Twill Uninv Olivia Carbon Recov Spooky PDrag Quick RecBit Alladin ======================================================================================================== %c-byte 166 150 100 175 166 125 150 125 125 150 150 100 %c-all 100 75 66 100 100 66 75 66 66 75 75 66 %c-bomb 33 50 33 50 33 33 50 33 33 50 50 33 cover-500 233 332 161 448 233 302 258 300 299 339 266 cover-1000 500 626 324 905 493 611 553 617 609 685 559 cover-2000 1036 1320 693 1783 1027 1219 1166 1279 1216 1365 1162 bomb core dat core dat+cor core dat dat dat dat dat dat core exec-lines 7 5 4 5 7 4 6 4 4 5 6 3 total lines 8 6 5 6 8 5 7 5 4+1 5+1 7 3 .f scan size 8 4 3 5 ~7 5 6 4 3 4 5 3 mod 5 1~17/4 2~? 2~10~17 5 1~5~2 8~4 1~ 1~2 2~ 1~ ~1 stone-gate 66 0 0 25 66 -33 +0 -33 -33 -25 -25 stone-djn Y Y N Y Y Y Y Y Y Y Y djn-type disc cont ~cont disc cont disc v-disc disc cont disc clear Y Y(2) Y Y Y Y Y Y Y Y Y N clear-size 1+2 3 3 3 1+2 3 1+2+1 3 3 3 2+1 clear bmb aImp dat sub dat aImp dat dat dat dat dat dat clear-type dc d sub dat dc dat d d d d rev-d suicidal N Y<30k N Y<29K N Y<35K Y<20K Y<35K Y<35K Y<35K N N clear-gate -100 0 0 0 -100 33 -25 0 33 -33 100 switch-0 5828 5019 12000+ 4784 5828 10647 4252 10216 10635 4201 4470 6x wilkies#100 131 114 105 108 138 117 99 112 120 113 121 105 oct2002#100 97 84 72 92 97 83 71 80 77 90 90 97 ======================================================================================================== Stat ST2 ======================================================================================================== %c-byte 150 %c-all 75 %c-bomb 50 cover-500 336 cover-1000 682 cover-2000 1364 bomb dat&spl exec-lines 5 total lines 6 .f scan size 6 mod 4 stone-gate -25 stone-djn Y djn-type cont clear Y clear-size 2+1 clear bmb aImp clear-type d suicidal N clear-gate +33 switch-0 4135 wilkies#100 122 oct2002#100 96 ======================================================================================================== Newt: loses to porchswing Candy: has 2 clears. top[main] drops to 2 procs and has dat for line #3. scores better than newt vs scanners, worse against stones loses to bluefunk & canonade Twill: 88-standard. Loses to porchswing, bluefunk & canonade Uninvited: Good coverage ... so why not benchmarking better? Fragile? Olivia: Is basically Newt. aImp bomb is better. Bomb is after body. Carbonite: Loses to bluefunk & canonade Recovery: Clears only ~66% of core. Loses porchswing, bluefunk, canonade Spooky Wench: Similar to carbonite but _doesn't leave a djn-trail_. Loses to bluefunk & canonade [does worse than carbonite] Better against f-scanners e.g. mini-HSA [mySpooky has dat bomb remote - scores a little better vs scanners] Pendragon: Turns into 33c clear/gate - with 2 procs only. Similar to Spooky but a) has gate in SPL b) bomb is remote c) uses dat {0, }0 to reduce vs f-scanners Quicksilver: More aggressive than Newt/Oliva but doesn't gate or dclear [designed to enter clear quickly and be imp-friendly?] Recycled Bits: Looses djn after 4470. After 7682 enters backward clear. After 31516 becomes 2inst perfect gate. ST2: JM's "Stone test 2" from r.g.c. 2..n clear wipes are 2/3core Better against papers. Loses canonade, marginally to bluefunk & porchswing === cover-counts: doesn't distingush between bombs and djn's. could do with a measure of spread doesn't detect bombing with empty core === pbt@waknuk:~/corewar/stone$ pmars -b -r 400 * Stone from Candy by Lukasz Grabun scores 681 Stone from Newt by Ian Oversby scores 477 Results: 213 145 42 Stone from Candy by Lukasz Grabun scores 768 Twill by Andy Pierce scores 345 Results: 227 86 87 pbt@waknuk:~/corewar/stone$ pmars -b -r 400 newt-stone.red twill.red Stone from Newt by Ian Oversby scores 881 Twill by Andy Pierce scores 191 Results: 251 21 128 pbt@waknuk:~/corewar/stone$ pmars -b -r 400 uninvited-stone.red newt-stone.red Stone from Uninvited by John Metcalf scores 584 Stone from Newt by Ian Oversby scores 560 Results: 176 168 56 pbt@waknuk:~/corewar/stone$ pmars -b -r 400 uninvited-stone.red candy-stone.red Stone from Uninvited by John Metcalf scores 561 Stone from Candy by Lukasz Grabun scores 627 Results: 183 205 12 pbt@waknuk:~/corewar/stone$ pmars -b -r 400 uninvited-stone.red twill.red Stone from Uninvited by John Metcalf scores 698 Twill by Andy Pierce scores 416 Results: 204 110 86 pbt@waknuk:~/corewar/stone$ pmars -b -r 400 uninvited-stone.red olivia-stone.red Stone from Uninvited by John Metcalf scores 575 Stone from Oliva by Ben Ford scores 566 Results: 172 169 59 pbt@waknuk:~/corewar/stone$ pmars -b -r 400 newt-stone.red olivia-stone.red Stone from Newt by Ian Oversby scores 470 Stone from Oliva by Ben Ford scores 482 Results: 74 78 248 pbt@waknuk:~/corewar/stone$ pmars -b -r 400 olivia-stone.red candy-stone.red Stone from Oliva by Ben Ford scores 464 Stone from Candy by Lukasz Grabun scores 701 Results: 143 222 35 Carbonite by Ian Sutton scores 576 Stone from Candy by Lukasz Grabun scores 609 Results: 187 198 15 Carbonite by Ian Sutton scores 532 Stone from Newt by Ian Oversby scores 544 Results: 136 140 124 Carbonite by Ian Sutton scores 496 Stone from Oliva by Ben Ford scores 583 Results: 125 154 121 Carbonite by Ian Sutton scores 777 Twill by Andy Pierce scores 342 Results: 232 87 81 Carbonite by Ian Sutton scores 570 Stone from Uninvited by John Metcalf scores 591 Results: 177 184 39 pbt@waknuk:~/corewar/stone$ pmars -b -r 1000 carbon.red candy-stone.red Carbonite by Ian Sutton scores 1536 Stone from Candy by Lukasz Grabun scores 1425 Results: 499 462 39 pbt@waknuk:~/corewar/stone$ pmars -b -r 1000 ../classic/mini-HSA.red carbon.red mini-hsa by Guenzel scores 1480 Carbonite by Ian Sutton scores 1519 Results: 493 506 1 pbt@waknuk:~/corewar/stone$ pmars -b -r 1000 ../classic/mini-HSA.red spooky-stone.red mini-hsa by Guenzel scores 571 Stone from Wintermute by John Metcalf scores 2404 Results: 182 793 25 pbt@waknuk:~/corewar/stone$ pmars -b -r 1000 ../classic/mini-HSA.red candy-stone.red mini-hsa by Guenzel scores 975 Stone from Candy by Lukasz Grabun scores 2013 Results: 321 667 12 pbt@waknuk:~/corewar/stone$ pmars -b -r 1000 ../classic/mini-HSA.red pendragon-stone.red mini-hsa by Guenzel scores 954 Stone from Pendragon by Christian Schmidt scores 1785 Results: 231 508 261 pbt@waknuk:~/corewar/stone$ pmars -b -f -r 2000 ../classic/mini-HSA.red pendragon-core.red mini-hsa by Guenzel scores 1351 Stone from Pendragon by Christian Schmidt scores 4594 Results: 432 1513 55 pbt@waknuk:~/corewar/stone$ pmars -b -f -r 2000 ../classic/mini-HSA.red pendragon-stone.red mini-hsa by Guenzel scores 1684 Stone from Pendragon by Christian Schmidt scores 3778 Results: 382 1080 538 === pbt@waknuk:~/corewar/bench/R4$ for i in ../../stone/*-stone.red; do echo -n "$i: "; koth $i 400 r4 2>&1 | grep Overall ; done ../../stone/candy-stone.red: Overall score is 128.730774 ../../stone/newt-stone.red: Overall score is 133.711533 ../../stone/olivia-stone.red: Overall score is 131.903839 ../../stone/pendragon-stone.red: Overall score is 118.750000 ../../stone/quicksilver-stone.red: Overall score is 123.019234 ../../stone/recovery-stone.red: Overall score is 90.115387 ../../stone/recycled-stone.red: Overall score is 139.442307 ../../stone/spooky-stone.red: Overall score is 116.961540 ../../stone/uninvited-stone.red: Overall score is 112.115387 === -r 400 Elapsed time: 968 seconds (00:16:08) Rank Name Author %W %L %T Score ___________________________________________________________________________ 1 Stone from Quicksilver Michal Janeczek 52 40 8 9142 2 Stone from Recycled Bit David M. Moore 49 35 16 9132 3 Stone from Candy Lukasz Grabun 48 45 7 8502 4 Stone from Pendragon Christian Schmidt 44 40 16 8286 5 Stone from Uninvited John Metcalf 45 44 11 8194 6 Stone from Wintermute John Metcalf 43 40 17 8187 7 Carbonite Ian Sutton 43 42 15 8102 8 Stone from Newt Ian Oversby 37 29 34 8084 9 Stone from Oliva Ben Ford 36 29 35 8017 10 my Spooky alteration PBT [John Metcalf] 41 43 16 7769 11 Stone from Recovery Ian Oversby 39 41 21 7644 12 Stone from Pendragon Christian Schmidt 20 43 37 5452 13 Twill Andy Pierce 24 50 26 5449